Food & Nutrition · Tea

Choosing water for tea: make the comparison useful

Browse the tea collection

Before changing the leaves and every brewing setting, check the water in the kettle. A useful comparison asks a narrow question: which of the suitable drinking waters available to you makes this particular tea more enjoyable?

In short: brew with water that is already safe to drink, and judge it by the cup, not by one number. Hardness, alkalinity, pH and dissolved solids each describe something different. Water can change the taste and look of the same tea, so the useful test is two drinking waters, one tea, the same recipe — and a note of which cup you prefer.

A stream of water pours from a metal kettle into a glass teapot on a kitchen counter.

Water poured from a kettle into a glass teapot.

Household tool teakettle pouring water into teapot — Wuerzele. CC BY-SA 4.0. Proportional resizing and WebP conversion; no crop or retouching. The original licence also applies to these derivatives.

Start with drinking water

Use water already suitable for drinking. A pleasing taste, a clear appearance or a low mineral reading cannot establish that water is safe. The US Centers for Disease Control and Prevention makes this distinction explicitly: harmful substances need not change water’s appearance, smell or taste. Follow any local drinking-water advisory rather than treating tea brewing as a solution to a water-safety problem. [1]

For the experiment below, compare your usual drinking water with another suitable, still, unflavoured drinking water. There is no need to collect spring water, buy laboratory water or add mineral powders.

Four different things a label might tell you

Hardness mainly describes dissolved calcium and magnesium. It is often reported as an equivalent amount of calcium carbonate, rather than as the separate amount of either mineral. USGS explains that these minerals can also contribute to deposits when hard water is heated. A kettle that develops scale therefore gives you a reason to investigate hardness, but not a complete analysis of your water. [2]

Alkalinity describes water’s capacity to neutralize added acid and resist a change in pH. Bicarbonate and carbonate can contribute to that capacity. This is different from simply saying that a water has a high pH. [3]

pH describes how acidic or basic the water is at the time it is measured. It does not, by itself, tell you the amount of calcium, magnesium or bicarbonate present. USGS treats pH as a distinct water measurement. [4]

Total dissolved solids, usually shortened to TDS, describes the combined amount of dissolved material. USGS lists several common contributors, including calcium, magnesium, sodium, bicarbonate and chloride. A total does not tell you how those components are divided. Two waters with similar totals need not have identical compositions. [5]

Copy the information the source actually gives: water origin, calcium, magnesium, bicarbonate or alkalinity, and TDS where reported. Preserve the units and leave gaps visible. In particular, “mg/L as calcium carbonate” is not a calcium value to put under a different heading.

More extraction does not necessarily mean more enjoyment

A controlled 2019 study compared particular green and black teas brewed in tap, bottled and deionized waters, holding brewing conditions constant. The water had a larger sensory effect on the green tea. For the green tea tested, bottled and deionized water produced higher measured levels of EGCG than tap water. The tap-water sample received higher overall liking ratings than the bottled-water sample; its difference from the deionized-water sample was not statistically significant. The work also documented differences in colour and cloudiness. [6]

Use the study to see why water is worth comparing, not to declare a winner between all taps and all bottles. Both labels cover different compositions. A clear cup and a cup you prefer are also separate observations.

Record preference on its own line, apart from appearance and intensity. You might value a stronger aroma in one cup and a gentler taste in another; the notes need not collapse those observations into one quality score.

Try a two-water comparison

Use a tea you know reasonably well and a recipe you already enjoy. This is a home comparison, not a laboratory test.

  1. Set out two matching, heat-safe brewing vessels and two matching drinking cups. Prepare equal portions of the same tea. Keep the cups labelled A and B underneath or on a nearby card.
  2. Choose the same water volume, brewing temperature and infusion time for both. Record the water identities separately. If someone can code the waters without telling you which is which, that can help reduce expectations.
  3. Heat each water using the same equipment and target temperature. With one kettle, empty it between waters and rinse it with a little of the next water. Respect its minimum-fill instruction. Brew sequentially if that is the practical option and note the timing difference.
  4. Remove the leaves after the same infusion time. Taste when both cups are comfortably drinkable and as close in temperature as practical. Very different serving temperatures make the comparison less informative.
  5. Write separate observations for aroma, bitterness, drying sensation, body and appearance. Finish with “prefer A,” “prefer B” or “no clear preference.”
  6. Repeat another day, reversing the brewing order and swapping which vessel receives each water. A preference that disappears on the second attempt deserves a smaller conclusion.

If you prefer one water repeatedly, compare it with a second tea before changing the whole routine. Keep the conclusion attached to the combinations you actually tried.

What water temperature is best for oolong tea?

Fuzhou’s market regulator advises freshly boiled water for dark tea, black tea and oolong, saying the aroma will be richer.[7] Whatever the temperature, use water already suitable for drinking.

Can I use tap water for tea?

If your tap water is safe to drink where you live, yes — it is a fair starting point. Safety comes first: CDC notes that harmful substances need not change how water looks, smells or tastes, so follow any local drinking-water advisory. [1] In one controlled study, the tap-water green tea was liked more overall than the bottled-water one. [6] That result belongs to the waters tested; the comparison below tells you about yours.

Is distilled or deionized water good for tea?

It is not necessary. In the 2019 study, deionized water gave higher measured EGCG in the green tea than tap water, yet tasters did not like that cup significantly more or less than the tap-water cup. [6] Higher extraction and a cup you enjoy are separate results — which is why this guide asks you to note your preference on its own line.

Does a water filter make tea taste better?

It depends on the filter and on the problem. CDC says pitcher and refrigerator filters commonly use activated carbon, often to improve taste and smell; what each filter removes varies, and maintenance matters. [1] If your current drinking water already makes a cup you enjoy, keeping it is a good result.

Decide whether a filter solves your problem

“Filtered” is not a single water composition. Check the particular filter’s documented purpose and maintenance instructions. CDC notes that pitcher and refrigerator filters commonly use activated carbon, often to improve taste and smell; their capabilities vary, and maintenance matters. [1]

Let the problem you want to solve guide a filter decision, rather than someone else’s favourite number. If your current drinking water makes a cup you enjoy, keeping it is a useful result. The aim is a repeatable choice and a clear account of what changed.

From Pavel’s tea table

Personal experience — Pavel Rachkouski, founder. One person’s notes, not advice.

The best water I have ever drunk came from a borehole in Belarus. The water in Minsk is not bad either. In Turkey and in Dubai I drink everything from bottles; it never even crossed my mind to brew tea with tap water there. Water tastes different in different places — every country has its own — but I don’t know how to describe it.

When we went up into the mountains, to the restaurant on Jebel Jais, I had a thermos with me, and when it ran low, the restaurant topped it up for us. I brought a gaiwan and three small travel cups. I’m not some great tea master, but I do carry a few things with me. We sat there for about three hours with milk oolong and plum GABA (the whole evening is on the GABA page).

I think everything depends on the person brewing: how the tea turns out comes down to them.

Sources

  1. Centers for Disease Control and Prevention. About Choosing Home Water Filters. Drinking-water safety, filter capabilities and maintenance; checked 16 October 2026.
  2. US Geological Survey. Hardness of Water. Definitions and scale formation; checked 16 October 2026.
  3. US Geological Survey. Alkalinity and Water. Acid-neutralizing capacity; checked 16 October 2026.
  4. US Geological Survey. pH and Water. Measurement explanation; checked 16 October 2026.
  5. US Geological Survey. Chloride, Salinity, and Dissolved Solids. TDS composition; checked 16 October 2026.
  6. Franks and colleagues. The Influence of Water Composition on Flavor and Nutrient Extraction in Green and Black Tea. Nutrients 11(1), 80, 2019. Primary study; public abstract and figure descriptions. No health-benefit conclusion adopted.
  7. Fuzhou Market Supervision Administration. Tea tips. Consumer guidance on preparing tea; Chinese-language source; checked 5 November 2026.
Line drawing: Pavel pours water from a kettle into a cup, with two glasses of water and two cups on the table; a cat watches.